Skip to ContentSkip to Footer

Preferred Mutual Insurance

At Joy Insurance, we pride ourselves on helping our customers find the coverage they need at an affordable price. That’s why we trust Preferred Mutual Insurance to provide our clients with the professional level of service they deserve.

Since our founding, we’ve helped countless people throughout New York save money and enjoy the peace of mind that a policy from Preferred Mutual Insurance provides. No matter your situation, our independent insurance agency can help you understand your exact insurance needs and find competitively priced options for your next policy.

Preferred Mutual Insurance Logo
Get A Quote

* indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Customer Reviews
5/5

The staff at this agency is excellent!!! They are always so personable and...

Stephanie Jansen
Stephanie J
5/5

I have been a customer with Joy Ins. for many years. The staff is always...

JS
Jay S
5/5

I understand how this insurance agency got their name as they are a joy to work...

ANNE SCHULMAN
ANNE S
5/5

This evaluation relates to the process of locating appropriate and affordable...

Stuart Stiles
Stuart S
5/5

Chris worked with me on purchasing life insurance. From the very beginning, he...

Joseph Amato
Joseph A